Comments on: And the winners are… http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/ Following Art Wherever It Goes | Sama-sama Ikut Seni Tue, 27 Dec 2011 05:46:49 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Zul Albani http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-15458 Zul Albani Mon, 19 Apr 2010 05:28:55 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-15458 Tak mau gaduh lo! malu la negara jiran art dia orang dah masuk WORLD katogeri. Orang Malaysia ni tak abih2 nak galuh sam sendili... Sama2 bantu lo...muda and tua ... tua and muda. Jangan asik2 yang tua je tak adil lo!!! Tak mau gaduh lo! malu la negara jiran art dia orang dah masuk WORLD katogeri. Orang Malaysia ni tak abih2 nak galuh sam sendili… Sama2 bantu lo…muda and tua … tua and muda. Jangan asik2 yang tua je tak adil lo!!!

]]> By: SANG KHECIL http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-9653 SANG KHECIL Fri, 13 Nov 2009 14:36:45 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-9653 RUPA-RUPANYA MASIH TERDAPAT RAMAI PENGIAT SENI CONTEMPORARY YANG WIDELY BELIEVED THAT THE NAME IS THE POWER, TAPI BUKANNYA THROUGH KNOWLEDGE AND UNDERSTANDING OF ART, BETUL-BETUL KESIAN LAH... CAN YOU IMAGINE HOW IF AN ARTIST, TERUTAMANYA SENIMAN LOKAL WILL SHOWED THEIR APPRECIATION WITH LOUD AND CHEERS TERHADAP KARYA-KARYA SENINAM YANG LAIN? ANY ONE OF YOU HAVE THAT KIND OF EXPERIENCE DARI SENIMAN GENERASI KEDUA SEPERTI EN.CHONG KAM KOW, DOK.ZAKARIA ALI, DOK.SULEIMAN ESA...ATAUPUN ZUL, JAI AND ARTIST MATAHATI WHICH ARE MUCH MORE YOUNGER IN THIS COUNTRY? ARE THEY LEBIH MEMENTINGKAN TRADING PROFIT SENDIRI SAHAJA? ATAU GILA TENTANG KUASA SIMBOLIK? JANGAN-JANGAN SYOK SENDIRI AJE! :p RUPA-RUPANYA MASIH TERDAPAT RAMAI PENGIAT SENI CONTEMPORARY YANG WIDELY BELIEVED THAT THE NAME IS THE POWER, TAPI BUKANNYA THROUGH KNOWLEDGE AND UNDERSTANDING OF ART, BETUL-BETUL KESIAN LAH…
CAN YOU IMAGINE HOW IF AN ARTIST, TERUTAMANYA SENIMAN LOKAL WILL SHOWED THEIR APPRECIATION WITH LOUD AND CHEERS TERHADAP KARYA-KARYA SENINAM YANG LAIN?
ANY ONE OF YOU HAVE THAT KIND OF EXPERIENCE DARI SENIMAN GENERASI KEDUA SEPERTI EN.CHONG KAM KOW, DOK.ZAKARIA ALI, DOK.SULEIMAN ESA…ATAUPUN ZUL, JAI AND ARTIST MATAHATI WHICH ARE MUCH MORE YOUNGER IN THIS COUNTRY?
ARE THEY LEBIH MEMENTINGKAN TRADING PROFIT SENDIRI SAHAJA? ATAU GILA TENTANG KUASA SIMBOLIK? JANGAN-JANGAN SYOK SENDIRI AJE! :p

]]> By: Tania http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-9639 Tania Fri, 13 Nov 2009 03:56:54 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-9639 Hide n seek time or peekaboo hahaha funnyla nk main sorok lak dia... Hide n seek time or peekaboo hahaha funnyla nk main sorok lak dia…

]]> By: Kenny http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-9585 Kenny Thu, 12 Nov 2009 08:37:57 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-9585 I do agree with those that request the identity panel judges to be revealed, as a strong panel of judges will add credibility to this award. Just imagine the following two panel of judges: A panel comprises of Latiff Mohidin, Tew Nai Tong, Dato Syed Ahmad Jamal, Khoo Sui Hoe and other names that we know. -vs- B panel that comprises of Ah Niao, Ah Kao, Ahmad, Abu, Arimuthu and anyone we pick on the street. Which one do you trust?? How do we know if all the judges in this "secret" panel are from Matahati group?? I disagree that the participants will create something to suit the judges' taste. I'm sure if 16 judges are professional, they know how to make impartial and independent judgement. So.. why and what are you hiding?? I do agree with those that request the identity panel judges to be revealed, as a strong panel of judges will add credibility to this award.
Just imagine the following two panel of judges:

A panel comprises of Latiff Mohidin, Tew Nai Tong, Dato Syed Ahmad Jamal, Khoo Sui Hoe and other names that we know.

-vs-

B panel that comprises of Ah Niao, Ah Kao, Ahmad, Abu, Arimuthu and anyone we pick on the street.

Which one do you trust?? How do we know if all the judges in this “secret” panel are from Matahati group??

I disagree that the participants will create something to suit the judges’ taste. I’m sure if 16 judges are professional, they know how to make impartial and independent judgement.

So.. why and what are you hiding??

]]> By: SANG KHECIL http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-9029 SANG KHECIL Fri, 30 Oct 2009 13:09:21 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-9029 YOU CAN IMAGINE MY SURPRISE WHEN MELIHAT YOU ORANG HANYA MEMENTINGKAN THE NAME OF DIA ORANG. MANAKALA, ADA PULAK ORANG MEMBERI COMMENT YANG SILLY TENTANG "A COMPETITION...DEPENDS ON WHO THE JUDGES WERE"! THE FACT IS, DO YOU THINK YOU ORANG AKAN MENANG DALAM MEA AWARD TAHUN YANG AKAN DATANG IF YOU KNOW WHO WERE THE JUDGES? ARE YOU MAKING ART FOR ATTRACTING DIA ORANG AJE? C'MON, IT IS JUST A GAME! THE OBJECTIVES AND RULES OF GAME IS MUCH MORE IMPORTANT THAN WHO WERE INVOLVED IN THE PROCESS OF JUDGING LA - "MATAHATI WANTS YOU"! WHAT DO YOU THINK? ^_^ YOU CAN IMAGINE MY SURPRISE WHEN MELIHAT YOU ORANG HANYA MEMENTINGKAN THE NAME OF DIA ORANG. MANAKALA, ADA PULAK ORANG MEMBERI COMMENT YANG SILLY TENTANG “A COMPETITION…DEPENDS ON WHO THE JUDGES WERE”!
THE FACT IS, DO YOU THINK YOU ORANG AKAN MENANG DALAM MEA AWARD TAHUN YANG AKAN DATANG IF YOU KNOW WHO WERE THE JUDGES? ARE YOU MAKING ART FOR ATTRACTING DIA ORANG AJE?
C’MON, IT IS JUST A GAME! THE OBJECTIVES AND RULES OF GAME IS MUCH MORE IMPORTANT THAN WHO WERE INVOLVED IN THE PROCESS OF JUDGING LA – “MATAHATI WANTS YOU”!
WHAT DO YOU THINK? ^_^

]]> By: csyong http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-9022 csyong Fri, 30 Oct 2009 10:18:38 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-9022 I cannot help but comment on the last comment, "WHY NOT JUST BIAR DIA ORANG SEBAGAI THE ANONYMOUS ART PROFESSIONALS?" The value (or lack of it) of a competition/ contest lies in the panel of judges. If these judges are not acknowledged experts on the subject matter, then the winners are just lucky that they are picked, maybe without merits - no different from lucky draws. Should the winners walk away with heads held high knowing that they truly deserve the title and prize money? In my opinion, all depends on who the judges were. I cannot help but comment on the last comment, “WHY NOT JUST BIAR DIA ORANG SEBAGAI THE ANONYMOUS ART PROFESSIONALS?”

The value (or lack of it) of a competition/ contest lies in the panel of judges. If these judges are not acknowledged experts on the subject matter, then the winners are just lucky that they are picked, maybe without merits – no different from lucky draws.

Should the winners walk away with heads held high knowing that they truly deserve the title and prize money? In my opinion, all depends on who the judges were.

]]> By: chin chin liew http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-9018 chin chin liew Fri, 30 Oct 2009 06:01:38 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-9018 Hi Sang Khecil, I think it is not a matter of being serious, information published should contain details and not gross over accuracy.I for one would like to get to know the professionals in art, why should we always "biar dia", is this the right attidute ? Or just Malaysian attitude? Hi Sang Khecil,
I think it is not a matter of being serious, information published should contain details and not gross over accuracy.I for one would like to get to know the professionals in art, why should we always “biar dia”, is this the right attidute ? Or just Malaysian attitude?

]]> By: SANG KHECIL http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-8998 SANG KHECIL Thu, 29 Oct 2009 15:05:25 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-8998 YOU GUYS ARE SO SERIOUS INDEED, FIRST DISKUSI, AND THAN, THE NAME OF JUDGES, WHY? WHY NOT JUST BIAR DIA ORANG SEBAGAI THE ANONYMOUS ART PROFESSIONALS? YOU GUYS ARE SO SERIOUS INDEED, FIRST DISKUSI, AND THAN, THE NAME OF JUDGES, WHY?
WHY NOT JUST BIAR DIA ORANG SEBAGAI THE ANONYMOUS ART PROFESSIONALS?

]]> By: chinchin Liew http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-8993 chinchin Liew Thu, 29 Oct 2009 10:58:23 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-8993 I am interested to know the names of the 16 art world professional as we may need their help in our upcoming art award. Thank you. I am interested to know the names of the 16 art world professional as we may need their help in our upcoming art award. Thank you.

]]> By: Haffendi http://www.arterimalaysia.com/2009/10/14/and-the-winners-are/#comment-8992 Haffendi Thu, 29 Oct 2009 10:49:04 +0000 http://www.arterimalaysia.com/?p=4698#comment-8992 please do provide names of the 16 art world professionals as Im an interested young artist who is seeking advice and guidance. please do provide names of the 16 art world professionals as Im an interested young artist who is seeking advice and guidance.

]]>